• wifinowglobal.com
  • syndicated.wifinowglobal.com
  • Wi-Fi NOW Global
  • Wi-Fi NOW Asia
  • Wi-Fi NOW Latin America

Wi-Fi NOW Global

  • Wi-Fi
  • Wi-Fi HALOW
  • ULTRA-WIDEBAND
  • RESOURCES
  • OUR PARTNERS
  • BECOME A PARTNER
  • BECOME A FREE MEMBER
  • WiFi NOW AUDIENCE INTELLIGENCE 2027
  • WiFi NOW WORLD CONGRESS 2027 PROSPECTUS
  • SERVICES
  • SHOP
  • EVENTS
    • CURRENT EVENTS
    • PREVIOUS EVENTS
    • EXPO
    • EventSpace®
  • RESOURCES
  • HALL OF FAME
  • ACADEMY
    • Masterclasses
    • Wi-Fi 7 PHY/MAC
    • 6 GHz operation including AFC
  • AWARDS
    • ABOUT AWARDS
    • CATEGORIES
    • WHY ENTER?
    • HOW TO ENTER
    • JUDGES
    • SELECTION CRITERIA
  • NEWS & TV
  • HALL OF FAME
  • ABOUT US
    • ABOUT Wi-Fi NOW
    • MANIFESTO
    • OUR RATINGS
    • OUR CREDENTIALS
    • MEET THE TEAM
    • CONTACT US
    • EventSpace®

Unlicensed 5G: Should the Wi-Fi industry start worrying?

December 17, 2018 | ANALYSIS | by Claus Hetting, Wi-Fi NOW CEO & Chairman

By Claus Hetting, Wi-Fi NOW CEO & Chairman

On December 13 the 3GPP cellular standardisation body committed to including 5G unlicensed in their next standards release (more details can be found in a Qualcomm blog here). In theory 5G unlicensed would directly compete with Wi-Fi. So should the Wi-Fi industry start worrying? The short answer is no. But it would also be wrong to dismiss the issue entirely. Here’s our take.

The beginnings of the much-anticipated 5G unlicensed – perhaps more aptly described as 5G in the Wi-Fi bands – has finally arrived: As of last week the process to include this version of 5G in 3GPP Release 16 has begun and will likely be completed some time in mid 2020. The prospective US release of 6 GHz bands for unlicensed use – perhaps already by end of next year – no doubt precipitated the 3GPP to get the work on unlicensed 5G kicked off sooner rather than later.

So what is 5G unlicensed? The 3GPP says it will come in two flavours: One will be called ‘stand alone 5G NR-U’ and this one is for unlicensed band use only. The other – which is more ominous – is called ‘LAA 5G NR-U’ where LAA stands for ‘License Assisted Access.’ This one uses a licensed band as an anchor (for signalling, stability, etc.) while the unlicensed bands do the heavy lifting.

Been there – done that – it flopped, remember?

Dejá vu anyone? Well – we’ve certainly been here before. Remember the LTE-U debacle of a couple of years ago? It was a long story mired in controversy but the gist of it was this: A conflict arose because LTE-U (a version of 4G in unlicensed bands) was suspected of badly degrading Wi-Fi performance wherever the services would overlap. In the end none of this mattered because LTE-U turned out to be a flop. The LAA version of 4G unlicensed also flopped.

Now the 3GPP is at it again except this time we’re in 5G territory. So will the transition from one G to the next transform cellular unlicensed from abject failure to spectacular success? The answer is no – and here’s why: The problem with cellular unlicensed is not technical. It’s structural.

A deeply red business case

The reason why these technologies fail is exactly the same reason why cellular small cells have had a very hard time getting off the ground at scale. Cost of densification is exceedingly high, returns are doubtful, the ecosystem is poorly equipped to get this started, which altogether means the business case adds up to red figures. The same will happen to 5G unlicensed simply because since the failure of LTE-U & its kin none of the structural issues have changed even a little.

And don’t forget: We already have small cells – they’re called Wi-Fi access points! As for the timelines, anything 5G unlicensed is already lagging behind Wi-Fi by a wide margin. Wi-Fi 6 is on track to hit the markets first half of next year and chipset vendors will have 6 GHz Wi-Fi solutions ready by end of next year – in time for what will hopefully be the FCC’s final ruling on 6 GHz unlicensed.

LAA technology is anti-competitive

But before we leave the subject beware of this: The use of licensed bands to anchor unlicensed services – regardless of whether the scheme uses Wi-Fi-like LBT politeness protocols or not – is anti-competitive and here’s why: There’s clearly a benefit to anchoring unlicensed services in licensed bands otherwise such a solution would never have been proposed. But remember that any such competitive advantage would only befall the owners of licensed spectrum.

This means that for example large MNOs would systematically gain competitive advantage over smaller Wi-Fi service providers without billion-dollar mobile licenses. If LAA-type schemes are allowed to go ahead by regulators the overarching principle at work here would be might is right.

This is simply the wrong set of values. One of the most important jobs for regulators is to take steps to protect smaller businesses against anti-competitive practices. And this one is obvious.

So here is our fervent appeal to regulators all over the world: That they immediately take steps to examine the potential for anti-competitive practices provided by future 5G LAA technology. In our view 5G LAA should never be permitted to operate anywhere.

/Claus.

Wi-Fi Industry News

November 17, 2026 [WWC ANNOUNCEMENT]

WiFi NOW World Congress 2027 expands into UWB, Bluetooth, and more – with Intelligent Connectivity in focus

November 16, 2026 [Weekly News Brief]

Roundup: Cisco revenue jumps 43%, Spectrum deploys Wi-Fi 7 for NBA, US Army hires Boldyn for managed Wi-Fi

November 14, 2026 [Research & Analysis]

The Bluetooth Technology Guide 2026-2027 including silicon/solutions tracker – download it here

November 11, 2026 [Ultra-wideband]

Now streaming on-demand: UWB in ACTION – Europe’s first dedicated UWB congress

November 11, 2026 [AI Operations]

Extreme Networks’ big bet on agentic AI Ops is paying off – and there’s much more to come

November 10, 2026 [Agentic AI]

GFiber teams up with Qualcomm to bring agentic AI directly onto a new Wi-Fi 8-capable home gateway

November 09, 2026 [Featured]

Roundup: MikroTik launches HaLow, Bluetooth HDT is official, Plume & Google dismantle botnet, FCC’s ultra-wideband NPRM

November 08, 2026 [New standards]

Interview: Wi‑Fi 8 isn’t about speed – but that’s exactly the point, says Cisco Wireless CTO Matt MacPherson

November 03, 2026 [Featured]

TECH WATCH: Preparing ultra-wideband for mass market adoption – with FiRa’s Sunil Jogi

November 02, 2026 [Featured]

TECH WATCH: Wireless convergence across Wi-Fi, 5G, and satellite – with SPARRO

Search

Resource Centre

Your hub for the latest Wi-Fi industry insights and resources

Research reports, in-depth technology guides and expert insights on Wi-Fi — new resources every week, free for members.

  • Solutions & Use Cases
  • Technology Guides
  • Expert Insights
Explore the Resource Centre →
  • Solutions & Use CasesWireless convergence in action: How SPARRO brings Wi-Fi, 5G, and satellite connectivity together for industrial enterprisesNovember 13, 2026
  • Expert InsightsUWB in ACTION October 29: The Year of Indoor Navigation – Inside Europe’s First UWB SummitNovember 11, 2026
  • Members onlySolutions & Use CasesBluetooth Silicon & Solutions Tracker 2026-2027: LE Audio, Auracast, Channel Sounding, & HDTNovember 7, 2026

Subscribe to Wi-Fi NOW

Stay updated on Wi-Fi News & Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Upcoming events

WiFi NOW World Congress 2027

April 19, 2027

Register now
All events

Latest white papers All white papers

New Aprecomm white paper: Understanding the business-critical shift from QoS ...

New paper: Enea publishes the definitive technical guide to Wi-Fi Offloading

New MediaTek Filogic paper on Wi-Fi 8 (802.11bn) highlights Ultra High Availa...

Upcoming Masterclasses

On-demand: Inside Wi-Fi 6E & Wi-Fi 7

MASTERCLASS: A JOURNEY INSIDE Wi-Fi 6E

Register now
All masterclasses

Wi-Fi NOW Services

Job platform

Stay updated on the latest jobs in the Wi-Fi industry.

Go to jobs

Wi-Fi Academy

Interested in the latest technologies in Wi-Fi?

Go to academy

Syndicated

The latest press releases from all Wi-Fi companies.

Visit syndicated
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Read more in our privacy statement. Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Wi-Fi NOW

Join WiFi NOW for free

Create your free account to access unique insights and industry resources.

  • Unlock articles
  • Access reports & resources
  • Download presentations
  • Watch webinars
  • Stay updated on the latest
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Already have an account? Log in

Log in

Don’t know your password? Click here to login with an e-mail link instead.

Forgot your password?
Don’t know your password?

Enter your e-mail below and we'll send you a login link.

No account yet? Join for free

Wi-Fi NOW (Hetting Global ApS), Denmark company registry no. 40955437
Hedeskovvej 9
DK-8520 Lystrup, Denmark.
Contact: Tlf: +45 25341705 / Claus Hetting

For questions or comments, please contact Chief Administrator [email protected]

Visa logo MasterCard logo JCB logo American Express logo

Terms of Purchase - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service